Number One With a Bullet is the fourth story featured in the first episode of Season 1.
On February 14, 1991, a woman named Sharon plans a honeymoon to Paris with her husband John for Valentine's Day. When Sharon arrives home, she spots a police car in the driveway and heads inside, finding clothes scattered all over the stairs as John has an affair with a fellow police officer. Sharon screams for the two to get out of her house and grabs John's gun. Distracted when the female police officer pulls out her gun, John struggles with Sharon for the gun, only to have it go off, shooting her and killing her. Sharon's friend and subordinate disguises herself and attempts to murder John while he mows the lawn, but the bullet misses him and lodges in a tree.
Five years later on February 14, 1996, John is now married to his lover, who asks for John to cut down a tree which has Sharon and John's initials carved in it (which is the same tree that Sharon's friend had shot a bullet into). As John cuts the tree, the bullet dislodges and pierces John's heart, the bullet finally finding its' intended target.
- Danielle Nicolet - Sharon's friend (Narrator)
- Laura Stockman - Sharon
- Al Sapienza - John
- Raquel Gardner - John's lover